


Question
How is carbon dating done?
Asked by:
William Baker
Answer
Carbon 14 (C14) is an isotope of carbon with 8 neutrons instead of the more common 6
neutrons. It is unstable, and scientists know that it radioactively decays by
electron emission to Nitrogen 14, with a half life of 5730 years. This means that
given a statistically large sample of carbon 14, we know that if we sit it in a
box, go away, and come back in 5730 years, half of it will still be carbon 14, and
the other half will have decayed.
Or in other words, if we have a box, and we don't know how old it is but we know it
started with 100 carbon 14 atoms, and we open it and find only 50 carbon 14 atoms
and some other stuff, we could say, 'Aha! It must be 1 carbon 14 halflife (or 5730
years) old.' This is the basic idea behind carbon dating.
So in the real world, looking at a sample like say a bone dug up by an
archaeologist, how do we know how much carbon 14 we started with? That's actually
kind of cool. It's a semilong story, so bear with me. In the atmosphere, cosmic
rays smash into normal carbon 12 atoms (in atmospheric carbon dioxide), and create
carbon 14 isotopes. This process is constantly occurring, and has been for a very
long time, so there is a fairly constant ratio of carbon 14 atoms to carbon 12
atoms in the atmosphere. Now living plants 'breathe' CO_{2} indiscriminately (they
don't care about isotopes one way or the other), and so (while they are living)
they have the same ratio of carbon 14 in them as the atmosphere. Animals,
including humans, consume plants a lot (and animals that consume plants), and thus
they also tend to have the same ratio of carbon 14 to carbon 12 atoms. This
equilibrium persists in living organisms as long as they continue living, but when
they die, they no longer 'breathe' or eat new 14 carbon isotopes
Now it's fairly simple to determine how many total carbon atoms should be in a
sample given its weight and chemical makeup. And given the fact that the ratio of
carbon 14 to carbon 12 in living organisms is approximately 1 : 1.35x10^{12}, we can
figure out how many carbon 14 atoms were in the sample when it ceased to replenish
it's supply.
In actually measuring these quantities, we take advantage of the fact that the rate
of decay (how many radioactive emissions occur per unit time) is dependent on how
many atoms there are in a sample (this criteria leads to an exponential decay
rate). We have devices to measure the radioactivity of a sample, and the ratio
described above translates into a rate of 15.6 decays/min per gram of carbon in a
living sample. And if you play with the exponential decay equations, you can come
up with the nice formula (1/2)^{n}=(current decay rate)/(initial decay rate), where n
is the number of half lives that have passed. Voila, now you can tell how old a
sample of organic matter is.
Some notes:
1) Obviously, this technique only works for dead organic material.
2) This technique is best for dating items which died between on the order of 1000
to on the order of 1,000,000 years ago. Carbon 14 dating is not great for dating
things like a year old because if much less than 1 halflife has passed, barely any
of the carbon 14 has decayed, and it is difficult to measure the difference in
rates and know with certainty the time involved. On the other hand, if tons of
halflives have passed, there is almost none of the sample carbon 14 left, and it
is really hard to measure accurately how much is left. Since physics can't predict
exactly when a given atom will decay, we rely on statistical methods in dealing
with radioactivity, and while this is an excellent method for a bazillion atoms, it
fails when we don't have good sample sizes. However it is possible, when dating
very old rocks for instance, to use longer lived isotopes for dating on a longer
time scale.
3) The assumption we based this on (that the ratio of carbon 14 in the atmosphere
and thus in living organisms is constant) is a decent one for ballpark figures, but
this method will not be able to give results accurate to, say, a couple of minutes.
For more info on carbon dating go to:
Answered by:
Gregory Ogin, Physics Undergraduate Student, UST, St. Paul, MN

